New Expansion Poll Thread

Discuss the MVC hoops season here.

Who should be the next two teams to join the Valley?

Denver
1
1%
Nebraska-Omaha
2
3%
North Dakota State
6
8%
Northern Kentucky
14
20%
Missouri-Kansas City
4
6%
Oral Roberts
4
6%
Texas-Arlington
4
6%
South Dakota State
9
13%
St. Thomas
15
21%
Wisconsin-Milwaukee
12
17%
 
Total votes : 71

Re: New Expansion Poll Thread

Postby Herd » January 30th, 2022, 8:42 pm

Campbellproud wrote:
professorbum wrote:Take NDSU off the list. Adding both Dakota States would have been a good move for the valley at one time. And it certainly would have excited NDSU fans. But not anymore. Honestly, a conference with UIC in it is meh. A Chicago commuter school spitting distance from some of the most dangerous neighborhoods in the city. No thank you. The Valley really has fallen if the leadership thought UIC was a good idea. Granted, the Summit isn't great. But we're already there and usually are a contender. So we might as well stay unless something develops on the football side.


NDSU is not on anyone’s list outside message boards. It’s at best a middling program in the middle of absolutely nowhere. NDSU is stuck in the Summit forever, so they just need to make the best of it. It was never mentioned as an option for the MVC, and never will given the direction of the league. There is literally no upside whatsoever to adding them or any of the Dakotas. They have a good football team, but the MVC could care less about that because it doesn’t have football. The MVFC does. I think UIC is a great add. You’ve clearly never been there and only believe what you hear about Chicago on Fox News. You’re clearly butt hurt that other teams got in when the league didn’t even sniff NDSU.


Campbell, are you kidding me, Campbell? Your from Campbell, and your throwing shade at North Dakota State. I have no idea what state something called Campbell is even in, but I know it’s not worth my time to listen to any pissant from Campbell’s ignorant opinion. Your from Campbell, are you kidding me?
Herd
MVC Bench Warmer
MVC Bench Warmer
 
Posts: 46
Joined: April 20th, 2017, 4:15 pm

Re: New Expansion Poll Thread

Sponsor

Sponsor
 

Re: New Expansion Poll Thread

Postby Campbellproud » January 30th, 2022, 10:05 pm

Herd wrote:
Campbellproud wrote:
professorbum wrote:Take NDSU off the list. Adding both Dakota States would have been a good move for the valley at one time. And it certainly would have excited NDSU fans. But not anymore. Honestly, a conference with UIC in it is meh. A Chicago commuter school spitting distance from some of the most dangerous neighborhoods in the city. No thank you. The Valley really has fallen if the leadership thought UIC was a good idea. Granted, the Summit isn't great. But we're already there and usually are a contender. So we might as well stay unless something develops on the football side.


NDSU is not on anyone’s list outside message boards. It’s at best a middling program in the middle of absolutely nowhere. NDSU is stuck in the Summit forever, so they just need to make the best of it. It was never mentioned as an option for the MVC, and never will given the direction of the league. There is literally no upside whatsoever to adding them or any of the Dakotas. They have a good football team, but the MVC could care less about that because it doesn’t have football. The MVFC does. I think UIC is a great add. You’ve clearly never been there and only believe what you hear about Chicago on Fox News. You’re clearly butt hurt that other teams got in when the league didn’t even sniff NDSU.


Campbell, are you kidding me, Campbell? Your from Campbell, and your throwing shade at North Dakota State. I have no idea what state something called Campbell is even in, but I know it’s not worth my time to listen to any pissant from Campbell’s ignorant opinion. Your from Campbell, are you kidding me?


Campbell was my dorm at UNI. I’m a UNI grad. I’ll throw shade at NDSU all day long. Your buddy in the quote, who has no affiliation with a Valley school, is coming on a Valley board to trash a new Valley member. They are clearly jealous that UIC got in over a Dakota school.

There are seemingly a lot of NDSU lurkers around here, to my continued amazement. I’m not sure why they come here, but if they do, they should remain respectful of our members—esp. if they are from somewhere like the Dakotas.
Campbellproud
MVC Role Player
MVC Role Player
 
Posts: 72
Joined: November 24th, 2020, 12:03 am

Re: New Expansion Poll Thread

Postby Herd » January 31st, 2022, 1:57 am

All this trashing of NDSU by UNI fans . . . Shows your character or lack thereof. Somewhere like the Dakotas? Are you kidding me, what an arrogant statement. Somewhere like the Dakotas, you mean like all of Iowa?
Herd
MVC Bench Warmer
MVC Bench Warmer
 
Posts: 46
Joined: April 20th, 2017, 4:15 pm

Re: New Expansion Poll Thread

Postby BCPanther » January 31st, 2022, 8:39 am

You know they make ointments and creams to take care of the raging butthurt fire you've got going on there...

Isn't there a Summit League board somewhere? Lakes still making Bisonville miserable?
BCPanther
MVC Hall Of Famer
MVC Hall Of Famer
 
Posts: 3193
Joined: August 8th, 2010, 9:10 am

Re: New Expansion Poll Thread

Postby TBS_20 » January 31st, 2022, 9:39 am

It does seem very personal for BC. He probably got beat up in Fargo one time
TBS_20
MVC starter
MVC starter
 
Posts: 255
Joined: June 11th, 2021, 10:08 am

Re: New Expansion Poll Thread

Postby Herd » January 31st, 2022, 1:00 pm

BCPanther wrote:You know they make ointments and creams to take care of the raging butthurt fire you've got going on there...

Isn't there a Summit League board somewhere? Lakes still making Bisonville miserable?


Butt hurt? Not at all, but listening to the garbage posted by UNI fans will get a response. Hopefully people reading this board understand the lack of truth the poor character you are demonstrating.
Herd
MVC Bench Warmer
MVC Bench Warmer
 
Posts: 46
Joined: April 20th, 2017, 4:15 pm

Re: New Expansion Poll Thread

Postby UICSAlum » January 31st, 2022, 8:53 pm

05Racer wrote:
professorbum wrote:..... Honestly, a conference with UIC in it is meh. A Chicago commuter school spitting distance from some of the most dangerous neighborhoods in the city. No thank you. The Valley really has fallen if the leadership thought UIC was a good idea.........


Where in Chicago isn't within spitting distance of a dangerous neighborhood these days?


I'm going to be the contrarian here. I'm a Chicago guy, but I'm siding with RacerJoe and professorbum because I can confirm both the commuter school and shady neighborhood stuff.

During my days at Circle Campus (what UIC was called before 1981), there were no dorms. I was living in the suburbs and I was a commuter, taking the train downtown. The last stop before Union Station downtown is Halsted Street, just south of the campus. In order to save time, I would get off there and walk north on Halsted. This is the neighborhood I would walk through to get to campus:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nUUyFrHERpU

This scene is shot on Maxwell Street and portrays a romanticized version of it, including a made-for-movie mock up of the Sunday flea market. The singer is John Lee Hooker, one of the pre-eminent electric bluesmen, hardly typical of the street musicians that actually worked the market. But it still captures the spirit of the place, as well as the physical condition of the buildings circa 1979.

One thing you don't see in that scene are the rats. There was a wholesale produce market (the South Water Market) two blocks west, which gave them an ample food supply. In fact, there were so many rats in that neighborhood (both rodent and human) that I used to joke with my classmates that I was actually getting to know them.

Let's talk about north of the campus, on the other side of the expressway. In the 70's, there was Greektown, and little else. The rest of the neighborhood consisted of abandoned warehouses and factories, and when you got to Madison Street you were in the heart of skid row. These photos (one from 1969, the other from earlier) will give you a feel for what west Madison Street was like until early 90's.

http://galleries.apps.chicagotribune.co ... r-20130814
https://brians1288.tumblr.com/image/127970335353

So yes, UIC (Circle Campus) was, in fact, a commuter school sandwiched between two of the raunchiest - if not THE raunchiest - neighborhoods in Chicago.

But here's the catch: Although what you are saying is accurate, it is accurate about places that NO LONGER EXIST.

This is what the corner of Maxwell and Halsted looks like today:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/k_vo_921/ ... nydsc-s600

This is looking northwest, and Granderson stadium is one block west. You won't be getting a blues serenade on the way to a baseball game, but you can stop by Starbucks (not in picture) for a frappucino.

Skid row is similarly unrecognizable, and instead of flop houses and roach-infested single room occupancies, this is the kind of housing that is available today:

https://www.coldwellbankerhomes.com/il/ ... _45459026/
https://www.727westmadison.com/gallery/
https://www.highrises.com/chicago/madison-901-condos/

Circle Campus is now UIC, and is no longer just a commuter school. Maxwell Street is now University Village, and skid row is now the West Loop.

UIC absolutely had a role in making this happen. But the real driver was the billions of dollars of private development in an area that runs from the BNSF tracks on the south, to the Northwestern tracks to the north, from the river to the east, and Ashland on the west. The scope of this transformation is unparalleled in Chicago history after the great fire, and the institution that is reaping the greatest benefit from it today is UIC, due to proximity. IMO, that, more than anything else, explains the growth in enrolment and reputation that UIC has seen in recent years.

Now, you may pine for Maxwell Street, skid row, or Circle. Many people do. And if you want to have a conversation about the pros and cons of gentrification, I will be happy to indulge you. But the conversation has to start from an acceptance that these places no longer exist, irrespective of whether you would like them to or not.

Oh, and the rats? Here's what the South Water Market is today:

https://www.wintercohen.com/subdivision ... chicago-il
UICSAlum
MVC Walk On
MVC Walk On
 
Posts: 5
Joined: January 11th, 2022, 12:20 pm

Re: New Expansion Poll Thread

Postby Greg » January 31st, 2022, 9:49 pm

Thanks for the archival footage UICSAlum. Brings back a lot of memories and shows the stunning changes for the better. It makes me think about the old meatpacking district, Fulton Market, that now has some of the finest restaurants, huge office growth with Google and others as well as residential growth. Crains Chicago business states " Jan 14, 2022 — Today, that neighborhood—Fulton Market—is unquestionably the hottest development spot in Chicago, and perhaps even in the Midwest."
Greg
MVC Bench Warmer
MVC Bench Warmer
 
Posts: 27
Joined: December 24th, 2021, 5:39 pm

Re: New Expansion Poll Thread

Postby VUGrad1314 » February 1st, 2022, 8:08 am

Herd wrote:
BCPanther wrote:You know they make ointments and creams to take care of the raging butthurt fire you've got going on there...

Isn't there a Summit League board somewhere? Lakes still making Bisonville miserable?


Butt hurt? Not at all, but listening to the garbage posted by UNI fans will get a response. Hopefully people reading this board understand the lack of truth the poor character you are demonstrating.


NDSU should only be considered by the MVC if we know for sure they aren't planning to go FBS. I just can't see them having the ability to pay for all the extra scholraships travel costs of their FBS league (which will be huge for them whether it's CUSA the Mountain West or the MAC) and also boost their budget in other sports to accommodate the jump up in competition that an MVC Olympic sports membership would require. Maybe I'm wrong but I feel that NDSU can aspire to one or the other but not both and that's assuming their interest is reciprocated no matter which path they choose. I've always felt that NDSU and SDSU were potentially interesting targets to boost the MVC despite their relative lack of population given that they are state flagships and I believe NDSU just achieved R1 status which is awesome) but I have always been particularly interested in SDSU given that they seem less football-centric than NDSU. As long as the Bison remain this committed to a sport that the MVC doesn't even sponsor (and let's be honest isn't even that relevant at the FCS level) I don't see how their Olympic sports can boost the MVC's profile sufficiently to justify an invite especially given the apparent increase in travel for every school that such an invite would entail.
VUGrad1314
MVC Hall Of Famer
MVC Hall Of Famer
 
Posts: 1971
Joined: May 27th, 2017, 9:05 pm

Re: New Expansion Poll Thread

Postby professorbum » February 1st, 2022, 1:21 pm

Look, in many respects, I'm sorry I weighed in. As I said in a previous thread, UIC is an outstanding school academically. I just don't think it measures up athletics-wise to the MVC...at least the MVC of old that I grew up being a fan of.

On the crime issue, I get it that neighborhoods around UIC have been gentrified over the years. But there's still a lot of crime. Locations matter. Just by comparison in the same city, look at Loyola.

These are 2019 figures, so they precede the spikes in crime we've seen in the past couple years.

At Loyola University, 5% of reportable incidents under Clery were arrests for major crimes. Major crimes are defined as murder, rape, robbery, aggravated assault, and arson. As a function of the student population, that comes out to 2.47 arrests per 1000 students (although the arrested may or may not be students themselves).

At UIC, arrests for major crimes is 33.7% of reportable incidents under Clery. That's 4.51 arrests for major crimes per 1000 students.

So there is a difference. I'm sure there are some MVC schools, past or present, that are less safe than UIC. I shouldn't have even included the crime comment. But having mistakingly mentioned it, I feel the need to defend that there was basis for my comment.

However, my primary point all along was that UIC has a commuter tradition (I was one of them) with no significant fan base for athletics. Maybe that's changing. If so, great. As I said elsewhere, I wish the MVC and UIC great success.
professorbum
MVC Recruit
MVC Recruit
 
Posts: 13
Joined: April 17th, 2017, 6:22 pm

PreviousNext

Return to Missouri Valley Conference Basketball

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 32 guests