I saw all or part of all nine games, so here are my thoughts:
Thursday Night
ISU vs ISU - decent game (honestly one of the best games in the tournament). I didn't much care who won, but I can't root for that school from Normal. Both schools brought bands and made some noise so it was at least entertaining.
Valpo vs UE. What a yawner. Besides being past my bedtime, neither school brought a band and Valpo doesn't have a mascot since they went and got all politically correct. At least UE brought their purple and orange clad riverboat gambler. I don't think more than 10 people in the stands actually cared who won.
I left right after half time and was in bed back in the Hilton at 9:30.
Friday
The day started with another snooze fest as UNI made the Redbirds look like a team without a coach. Oh, wait. My bad. At least both schools seemed enthusiastic and UNI brought a decent crowd.
Loyola-Bradley looked like a good match on paper. Didn't turn out so. Not sure if Bradley was intimidated by all the Harry Potter scarves or Sister Jean or both, but it wasn't much of a game. At least the Gargoyle is kinda cute in a creepy sort of way and we got to see him for a few minutes.
When the night session started, I had high hopes for some entertaining games. JQH State, as I already knew, had the most talent on the floor this weekend and it showed as they wore down Valpo in the 2nd half. The Sugar Bears were equally talented and looked dapper and that kept me entertained for a short while.
Then it was time for the Main Event: Drake vs SIU. Ironically, both teams stayed at the Hilton at the Ballpark, so fans were intermingling all weekend. Not sure what dog breeders would say about bulldogs and salukis mixing it up would say, but it surely would produce some ugly dawgs. And, oh the irony that the Drake all session ticket holder were right in front of the Saluki faithful at the car rental arena.
Unfortunately, that's where the comparisons end. It was nip and tuck for most of the first half. Neither team did much offensively until the Salukis went on a tear with about 6 min left and took a 24-17 lead. then I blinked and the next thing I knew it was half-time and Drake led 28-26.
The second half wasn't pretty for my Salukis. We got down early and Drake never looked back. Other devastating loss at the Arch. It didn't help much when we saw all the excited Drake fans celebrating in the lobby at the Hilton.
Suggestion #1, each team needs their own hotel. Period. The Valley needs to work on that. The hotel "shortage" will be worse next year with two extra teams. I hope someone at the Valley office knows that Murray and SIU at the same hotel is NOT a viable option for next year.
Saturday
Everyone had high hopes that UNI and the Sister Jeans of Chicago could have another exciting game in the first semifinal. Didn't happen. The Rogers Park wolves took control and UNI never really made much of a run. UNI, with no chance at an at-large bid, saw their hopes crumble. Even the COY Ben Jacobs seemed befuddled. Frankly, the most entertaining thing during this game was the Loyola fan who stood and "danced" the whole game which prompted an obscenely drunk UNI fan to come over their section and start talking smack. He got booted by security. That was fun and I congratulated the usher for a job well done! Best laugh of the day.
The second game lived up to the hype and surpassed all expectations. Both teams played their hearts out, their fans held their breath awaiting the outcome and the game went into OT! Great game. I wasn't sure the blocking foul on Mosely at the end of the game was legit until I watched the replay (it was). Since Drake was at my hotel, I was able to congratulate Coach DeVries in the elevator later that night. Nice guy. (I think he might have been a little afraid of me when he saw the gnarling Saluki on my shirt).
The championship game, unfortunately, was disappointing. Loyola had an easier route and earlier schedule thanks to their seeding. Seeds 4-5 have an easier schedule at Arch Madness than the third seed. Drake did give a valiant effort and man, Tucker Devries, is the best freshman I've seen in the Valley since Doogie McBaskets played at that Nebraska school (which shall remain nameless).
Suggestion #2 Increase security and let people with MVC tickets ride the Metrolink for free. In all honesty, the metrolink didn't feel particularly in broad daylight let alone at night.
Suggestion #3 - lower ticket prices for all-session tickets or, by all means, do NOT raise ticket prices for next year. With the change in format next year, the Valley will be lucky to have anyone not wearing a short skirt at the games on Thursday afternoon.
Suggestion #4 - Financial penalties for not bringing a band or mascots. Drake didn't bring Spike and since Valpo got all politically correct on us, they don't even have a mascot. This is unacceptable. Not bringing a band isn't even D2 or D3, it's NAIA. What was up with that?
Suggestion #5 - tell the University presidents to schedule spring break to not conflict with Arch Madness so students can be encouraged to come. There were virtually no students (except for the Catholic University of Rogers Park) at the games. Then, seat them as close to the court as possible.
In summary, don't get your hopes up about Murray City College bringing loads of fans. The vast majority of the Murray fans that have been showing up in Evansville lives across the river in Henderson County where they have an extension campus. Factor in time, travel and the COST of hotels and tickets in St Louis, the crowd will be sparse. They won't go 20-0 in the Missouri Valley next year. Belmont and UIC will have minimal impact.
The Valley desperately needs SIU, ISUred and Bradley to improve and bring more fans.